Two-unit home · Off-market sale
Balancing family, fairness, and timing
Selling a probate duplex with a long-term tenant in place
Background
The estate included a two-unit residential property that the Personal Representative was responsible for selling as part of an estate settlement. The lower unit had been occupied by the former owners, while the upper unit was rented to a long-term tenant who was also a family member. While the family was aligned on the decision to sell and maintained positive relationships, they were concerned about how the tenant situation would affect the process.
The challenge
The primary challenge was how to market the property with a tenant still in place. The tenant was paying well below market rent, had accumulated a large amount of personal belongings, and smoked in the unit, all of which made traditional marketing difficult. The family worried that requiring the tenant to move out could take a long time and potentially create conflict. At the same time, they feared that listing the property with the tenant still there would discourage buyers.
How I helped
After touring the property and establishing a clear valuation, I worked with the Personal Representative to walk through multiple strategies. We discussed the tradeoffs between listing the property traditionally versus pursuing an off-market approach. Given the circumstances, I recommended an off-market strategy that focused on identifying buyers who could look past the tenant situation and understand the long-term potential of the property. To offset the reduced buyer pool, we started with a higher price supported by market data.
The outcome
The property was marketed selectively to a small group of investors and potential buyers. The family also reached out to extended relatives and contacts. Ultimately, a grandson of the former owner expressed interest in purchasing the property. Because he was familiar with the tenant, he was not discouraged by the situation and felt confident that they could reach a mutually beneficial arrangement. The sale moved forward smoothly and at a price the family felt was fair and defensible.
Why this matters
Every probate sale has its own complications. In this case, a flexible strategy and neutral guidance allowed the estate to move forward without displacing a tenant, creating family conflict, or raising concerns about fairness.